Book 181: The Pluto Files by Neil deGrasse Tyson


The Pluto Files by Neil deGrasse Tyson

Finished reading on July 1st, 2015

Rating: 7/10

I picked this book up because of New Horizons approach to Pluto and because I’d want to understand the whole hullabaloo around Pluto’s status change.

The book was interesting, but if you take a side – pro planet Pluto or pro dwarf-planet Pluto, it’ll feel as if you’re in an argument here. And it just feels silly to me. I think it might have to do with me living in Eastern-Europe and Pluto being discovered by an American – my feelings can be put together into one word – “meh”. So reading this book was ok, you do find out more about the situation and the discovery of Pluto and who were supporting Pluto to stay a planet, but you don’t really find out much about Pluto as such (but we will in about a week, right?).

It would be interesting to know what some other people thought of this book or just the topic of planetary status – would you have liked Pluto to remain a planet? Does it even matter when scientists decide that one thing is something else?

Book 89: How I Killed Pluto And Why It Had It Coming by Mike Brown

7963278Finished reading on November 25th, 2013 (my birthday! 🙂 )

Rating: 10/10

“How I Killed Pluto And Why It Had It Coming” by Mike Brown is a book about the discovery of some large icy objects in orbit around the Sun in the Kuiper belt. It tells the story of the discoveries of Sedna, Makemake, Haumea and Eris. You can find out how these objects were discovered and who were the scientists behind the discovery.

It is a rather personal account, as Mike Brown was the leading scientist working on trying to find other objects past the orbit of Pluto. Besides finding out his thoughts and feelings on those objects, there’s also quite an entertaining (for the reader, though it probably wasn’t too entertaining for the author) part about how Mike tried to use the scientific method for raising his newborn daughter. For example he tried to find out whether or not the baby sleeps longer when she’s been fed by her mother or when Mike just gives her the bottle. And the birth of Lilah (Mike’s daughter) coincides with the announcement of some of the objects so he has to deal with a lot of publicity. There’s also some drama involved with the discovery of one of the objects, but you can read more about that in the book.

Now one of the most important parts is the “killing Pluto” part. Do you have strong feelings for this dirty ice-ball? If you do, this book might not be for you, or maybe it might make one see reasons behind Pluto’s demotion… Mike Brown is “the killer of Pluto” because as there were new objects discovered near Pluto that were sometimes bigger than Pluto, then it became necessary to classify those objects. With asteroids it’s simple. But planets? Well the problem was that there was no definition for “planet”, only the concept of planet. And so when International Astronomical Union tries to get twelve planets into the Solar System, with Mike’s Eris being one of the planets, Mike starts an attack on the definition, showing why Pluto shouldn’t be a planet. And as you know, Pluto’s not a planet anymore, so if you want to know more about the back-story, of what happened and why it’s not a planet, read this book!